AGAINST

Wang Shichuan

China Youth Daily

Xie's research involves studies on human health and his election should have been approved by prestigious experts working in the medical field.

Xie is famous for his research on reducing the harm of cigarettes. But the FCTC has specifically pointed out that any terms about low-tar cigarettes are fake and misleading to smokers. Further evidence is that the death rate of lung cancer has increased rapidly over these years.

This is not the first time that Xie became one of the candidates for the CAE academicians. Xie applied for the honor in 2007, 2009 and 2011. Why should he be successfully elected this time but not four years ago or two years ago? It's impossible that his research achievements have changed a lot during this short period of time.

Although Xie is only a researcher, the institute he works for is affiliated with the China National Tobacco Corp. Once Xie is widely known as a CAE academician, the concept of "low-tar cigarettes" will be legitimized. Tobacco companies who use "low-tar" in their promotional activities will have more courage and evidence to do it in the future. Smokers will have more reasons to avoid quitting the bad habit because they will assume low-tar will bring less harm to their bodies. All these will make the tobacco industry more powerful and help smoking expand more quickly in China.

Qiao Hongge

Shanxi Evening News

Academician is the highest honor for scientists in China. It shouldn't be an honor that can be given as a present randomly but should be conferred to the best researcher. And "best" means his or her research fruits should give ordinary people more happiness, push forward social progress and help the development of all human beings. It's almost a laughing stock that a scientist working on tobacco science could be given a seat in the elite CAE.

Besides, it is an internationally common practice that science and research institutes should distance themselves from tobacco interests while, in this case, the institute Xie works for is affiliated to China's largest tobacco company and most of its research is sponsored by the tobacco industry. How can we believe in the results of Xie's research?

In foreign countries, the government should never sponsor this kind of research, which not only doesn't protect people's health but could increase the number of smokers. Researchers in the United States discovered that low-tar cigarettes don't reduce the risk of lung cancer.

There is no safe level of tobacco consumption. Smokers are more likely to inhale more when they consume low-tar cigarettes, and that actually increases the health risks.

Pan Hongqi

Beijing Youth Daily

Questioning the tobacco academician is bringing back the truth and conscience of science. What people really care about is whether Xie's research has really made tremendous and creative contributions to reducing the harm of cigarettes and protecting people's health.

The WHO has emphasized many times that all tobacco products, including low-tar cigarettes, are harmful for human beings. It's quite irresponsible for the elite CAE to give Xie the title of academician. It will discredit China's smoking-control efforts, which need concerted strength from all circles of society. It will bring a misleading concept for common people and have huge negative influence for the smoking-control authorities in the country.